NEW YORK — As Francisco Lindor stepped in against Phillies reliever Carlos Estévez with the bases loaded, one out, and the Mets down a run in the sixth inning, the Citi Field fans were still singing his walk-up song: When it’s cold outside, I’ve got the month of May. The Mets shortstop called time, retreated, and regrouped. The singing continued. I guess you’d say, What can make me feel this way? My girl, my girl, my girl Talkin’ ‘bout my girl, my girl
They punctuated their sweet serenade with three letters, shouted repeatedly in succession. “M-V-P! M-V-P! M-V-P!”
Lindor returned to the batter’s box, tapped the outside edge of the plate, then the inside one. Now, he was ready to break the game open. With the count 2-1, Estévez reared back and delivered his fourth straight fastball, a 99-mph belt-high heater over the outer third of the plate. Lindor unloaded. His smooth lefty stroke smacked the projectile flush, piercing it into the right-center field gap at 109.5 mph. It sailed over the wall and into the Phillies’ bullpen for a grand slam. Off the bat, it was clear that Lindor’s bullet in the gap would give his team the lead, but then it just kept going and going. Kinda like his team. The grand slam propelled the Mets to a 4-1 win in Game 4 of the National League Division Series on Wednesday night and guaranteed that their improbable postseason push would continue for at least another round.
The home run was the perfect encapsulation of these Mets during their rip-roaring last two weeks. It was simultaneously unimaginable and inevitable. “The whole time the inning is unfolding, [I’m thinking] Lindor is going to do it again,”
said manager Carlos Mendoza. “There’s no panic. The way he controls the emotions and he hits that ball. It’s unbelievable.”
The Mets certainly didn’t make things easy. They loaded the bases in each of the first two innings against Phillies starter Ranger Suárez but failed to capitalize. With one out in the first, Mark Vientos hammered a 2-2 sinker that leaked back over the plate into the left-center gap for a double. Brandon Nimmo then walked to bring up Pete Alonso, who worked the count full before grounding a dribbler to third base. Alec Bohm fielded it, and reached to try and tag Vientos running by him, but Vientos avoided it; the attempted tag not only cost Bohm time, but it also caused him to bobble the exchange. By the time he recovered and fired across the diamond, Alonso was making his final lunge toward the base. Initially called out, the Mets challenged, and the call on the field was overturned: Alonso beat the throw to the bag. Somehow, Alonso was credited with an infield single on the play.
It looked like Suárez would unravel right then and there, but he buckled down. He struck out Jose Iglesias with a three-pitch, curveball-changeup-curveball sequence and then whiffed J.D. Martinez with more soft stuff. After 30 stressful pitches, Suárez escaped unscathed.
One of the big questions entering Game 4 was which version of Suárez the Phillies would get: Would it be the pitcher who led the majors with a 1.83 ERA over the first three months of the season, or the one whose stuff was so diminished over his final 11 starts that opposing hitters combined for the same OPS that Fred McGriff had during his Hall of Fame career? Turns out, he was a combination of both. He clearly didn’t have his best stuff or command; his curveball was the only pitch in his arsenal that was working. But oh, it was working. He leaned on it in the second inning to get out of another bases-loaded jam. After a leadoff walk to Starling Marte and a scorching single by Tyrone Taylor, Suárez started spinning curves again, striking out Francisco Alvarez and Lindor on nearly identical deuces in the dirt. Vientos then bounced a grounder to third. The play was slow to develop and Marte was at third by the time Bohm fielded it. He had trouble getting it out of his glove and ate it instead of risking a throwing error. Bohm was bailed out for the second straight inning when Nimmo grounded out to end the threat.
Bohm was one of the best players in baseball during the first half of the season, but he combined for a 74 wRC+ in August and September. Things got even worse once the playoffs began. He was benched in Game 2 — the one game the Phillies won — and in Game 3 he was thrown out trying to stretch a single into a double. That was his only hit in the series.
Alonso walked to lead off the third inning, but then Suárez settled in. He struck out Iglesias with more curveballs and then got Martinez to ground into a 6-4-3 double play. Meanwhile, Mets starter Jose Quintana was cruising through the first three innings, carving up a Philadelphia lineup that had lost its potency. In the fourth, though, the Phillies got something going. Bryce Harper walked with one out, and Nick Castellanos lined a double over Nimmo’s head in left. The Mets brought the corners in for Bohm, who for all his woes this series did just enough to give the Phillies the lead. He grounded to third where Vientos, ranging to his glove side, fielded it, turned to throw home to get Harper, and then lost control of the ball. Everyone was safe. (Vientos was charged with an error on the fielder’s choice, so Bohm couldn’t even get credit in the box score for driving in the run.) The next batter, J.T. Realmuto, lifted a shallow fly ball to right field that wasn’t deep enough to score Castellanos. Quintana then got Bryson Stott to fly out to center for the final out.
Leading off the fifth, Lindor saw yet another curve from Suárez and wrapped it inside the third base line and into the left field corner. Vientos then walked. Suárez stayed in the game to face Nimmo, who struck out looking on a sinker at the knees. Finally, Phillies manager Rob Thomson went to his bullpen with two on, one out, and Alonso due up. Jeff Hoffman entered and caught Alonso looking at a front-door slider, which slid just enough to clip the corner, before Iglesias grounded out in front of home plate. Once again, the Mets left a runner in scoring position.
As was the case in Game 1, the Phillies scored a run early but couldn’t add to their lead, allowing the Mets to mount a comeback. Facing Quintana for a third time, Harper hooked a double to right field, prompting Mendoza to go to his bullpen — Reed Garrett for the trio of righties due up and then David Peterson for lefty Bryson Stott. Harper was left stranded at second. “As far as our offense is concerned, I thought the Mets did a real good job on us,”
Thomson said. “I thought we had pretty good at-bats today, and not much to show for it. But we had a couple of opportunities and Quintana pitched pretty well. But offense comes and goes, and it’s hard to explain, really.”
What happened next isn’t hard to explain, however. Thomson left Hoffman in too long. At this point in his career, Martinez is mostly a platoon DH against lefty pitching. That’s why he was in the lineup for Game 4. But even with Hoffman in the game and no lefties ready in the bullpen, Mendoza stayed with Martinez instead of pinch-hitting for him with Jesse Winker, and the veteran slugger promptly rewarded his manager with a single to center. He advanced to second on a wild pitch, and then following a Marte hit by pitch, both runners moved up on another wild pitch. Hoffman issued another free pass to Taylor to load the bases and bring up Alvarez, and still Thomson stuck with his right-hander. With the infield in, Alvarez grounded to shortstop Trea Turner, who fired home in time to get Martinez and keep the Mets off the board.
